Where to Eat Right Now in Harbour Island

Harbour Island’s dining scene is always evolving, with new openings and timeless favorites keeping things fresh. Here’s our roundup of where to eat on the island right now:

Ocean View Club

If you’re searching for the epitome of barefoot chic, Ocean View Club is it. A boutique property as well as a restaurant, it embodies the farm-to-table spirit with a touch of bohemian glamour. The dining space is intimate, shaded by palms and kissed by ocean breezes, making it one of the most atmospheric places to dine on the island.

The menu shifts with the seasons and what’s available locally, but expect fresh seafood, bright salads, and dishes that highlight produce from nearby farms. There’s a soulful quality to the meals here — unfussy, delicious, and deeply connected to the island. Dinner feels like gathering at a stylish friend’s beach house, complete with candlelight, laughter, and the sound of the waves beyond.

Hours vary; best to book ahead, especially for dinner seatings.

AcquaPazza

AcquaPazza has long been one of Harbour Island’s most celebrated dining rooms, and its recent move into the former Baretta’s site on Nesbitt Street has only added to its charm. Now a little closer to town, the restaurant still manages to hold onto its romantic feel. There’s a refined ease to the space,  polished enough for a special evening out, but never stuffy. 

The menu leans Italian at heart but with a distinctly Bahamian accent. House-made pastas are tossed with local grouper, conch, and garden-fresh produce, while small plates like grilled octopus and tuna carpaccio showcase the island’s bounty with a Mediterranean twist. Regulars rave about the eggplant parmesan layered with conch, and the seafood “Acquapazza” pasta is as beautiful as it is comforting. An impressive wine list, vegetarian options, and gluten-friendly dishes round out the menu, making it versatile for couples, families, and groups of friends.

Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM; reservations strongly recommended in peak season.

The Landing

Few places capture Harbour Island’s history and elegance as well as The Landing. Housed in a colonial-era building overlooking the harbour, it blends classic Bahamian charm with a refined dining experience. Walking inside feels like stepping into a piece of the island’s story, complete with polished wood, high ceilings, and a terrace that invites a slow evening meal.

The menu balances tradition and sophistication. Fresh seafood is always at the center, paired with seasonal produce and flavors that draw from both Bahamian and international influences. It is the kind of place where you might linger over a beautifully cooked snapper, enjoy brunch on the weekend, or start the day with their famous banana pancakes. For many, The Landing is less a restaurant and more a rite of passage, the spot you return to year after year for its quiet consistency.

Open daily for breakfast and dinner, with brunch on weekends. Reservations are recommended for dinner service.

Da Vine (Sushi & Wine Bar)

Da Vine brings a taste of Japan to Harbour Island with surprising elegance. This intimate sushi and wine bar has become a favorite for those craving something beyond the island’s staples. The space is sleek and cozy, perfect for date nights or small groups, with the buzz of clinking glasses and chefs rolling sushi behind the counter.

The menu blends creativity with authenticity. Signature rolls like the Briland Living or the Da Vine sit alongside dishes such as black cod and lobster tempura. Pair them with a thoughtful wine list or a sake flight, and you have one of the island’s most distinctive dining experiences. Often described as a hidden gem, Da Vine feels unexpected in such a small town yet perfectly at home in Harbour Island’s mix of charm and surprise.

Open for lunch and dinner. Dinner reservations are strongly encouraged.

Rooster Tail Bar & Grill

For a relaxed marina-side hangout, Rooster Tail Bar & Grill is a favorite where island days roll seamlessly into lively nights. Signature cocktails pair perfectly with the view of boats gliding in and out of the harbour, while the menu balances casual comfort with elevated touches, from fresh local seafood to classic favorites after a sun-soaked day on the beach or water. Stop in for Happy Hour every day and, on select evenings, enjoy live entertainment that makes the setting even more memorable.

Open daily from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Reservations recommended especially during sporting events and the holiday season.